Richter: The New Four Seasons: Vivaldi Recomposed (CD review)

Max Richter, Moog synthesizer; Elena Urioste, solo violin; Chineke! Orchestra. Deutsche Grammophon 4862769.

By Karl W. Nehring

Vivaldi’s The Four Seasons has long been a favorite of classical music fans, often serving as the gateway drug that hooks innocent young ears on the genre. From Vivaldi to Mozart to Beethoven and before long, the unthinkable – they find themselves addicted to Mahler, or in extreme cases, they might even find themselves frantically seeking out alternative editions of Bruckner symphonies. For Vivaldi fans old and new, there are countless recordings of the piece available, including the recent version by I Musici recently reviewed by John J. Puccio: https://classicalcandor.blogspot.com/2022/05/vivaldi-le-quattro-stagioni-cd-review.html. If you take a look at John’s review, you will note that I Musici themselves have recorded the work several times over the years, but they are certainly not the only recognizable musical name to have had more than one go at recording Vivaldi’s greatest hit. Still, it was surprising to learn that composer Max Richter (b. 1966) has now released the second recording of his “recomposed” version of Vivaldi’s masterpiece. The first release, titled Recomposed by Max Richter: Vivaldi, The Four Seasons, featured Daniel Hope on solo violin with the Kammerorchester Berlin under conductor André de Ridder along with Richter on electronic synthesizers. It was initially released by Deutsche Grammophon in the summer of 2012 and then later rereleased in 2014 in an expanded version that was also reviewed in Classical Candor by John Puccio: https://classicalcandor.blogspot.com/2014/04/recomposed-by-max-richter-cd-review.html 

Now, a decade later, we have another recomposition of the score by Richter, this time around one of the main differences being that not only do we have (other than Richter) different musicians, but they are playing different sorts of instruments. According to the liner notes, both the Chineke! Orchestra (a British ensemble consisting primarily of Black, Asian, and other ethnically diverse musicians) plus violin soloist Elena Elena Urioste “are playing on gut strings and period instruments: the sort that Vivaldi would have heard, and played in his own time.” Richter says of this new version that “I don’t see this as a replacement, but it is another way of looking at the material. It’s like shining a light through something from a fresh angle. There’s a romance about that, as if a layer of dust has been blown off… I love the slight grittiness and earthy feeling that gut strings have. I wanted to match that flinty, haptic, tactile texture with the electronic elements.”

In keeping with the “early instruments” theme, it turns out this time around, Richter did not avail himself of the latest sorts of electronic instruments, but rather played his synthesizer parts on an early Moog dating from the 1970s. Moreover, the recording was mixed not digitally, as you might well take for granted these days, but rather on an analog mixer. Richter explains that “those [Moogs] are the first-generation synths…They have a certain presence and authority about them. I mean, they are crude in a way, but they are also like someone inventing the wheel. They have gravitas.” Indeed, the synthesizer does add weight and yes, gravitas to the proceedings, as Richter uses it at times to add bass underpinnings that of course Vivaldi would never have imagined but which add a foundation to the sonic structure that sounds entirely natural and appropriate. Although the idea of a synthesizer might strike fear into the minds of some potential listeners, rest assured that Richter does not use the Moog in such a way as to call attention to itself. Instead, the sound of the Moog fits right in with the rest of the ensemble. I mentioned the occasional use of the Moog to provide a bass foundation to the sound, but another welcome way that Richter employs the Moog is by making it sound like a harpsichord – an instrument that always adds charm to the sound of the Seasons. And speaking of sound, the sonics of this release are superb, with solidity and quite believable imaging. The engineering team (Rupert Coulson, recording engineer and mixing; Alice Bennett, recordist and editing; Götz-Michael Rieth, mastering) did a remarkable job on this one. Kudos to the whole team!

So… what have we here? This is certainly not just another recording of Vivaldi’s The Four Seasons. Vivaldi’s venerable compostion, so familiar and so beloved to so many, truly has been “recomposed.” However, it has not lost its essential character. Richter’s version is clearly a version that is faithful to Vivaldi’s vision. If you enjoy the energy, drive, color, and variety of Vivaldi’s original, you will very likely get quite a kick out of Richter’s 2022 recomposed version, which has energy, drive, color, and variety in abundance, and is appropriately well-performed and well-recorded to boot. What a hoot!

KWN