There was a time in the old vinyl era when record
companies would barely fit Schubert’s Ninth
Symphony on a single LP. Now, it’s commonplace to find not only the Ninth but an accompanying Schubert
symphony on the same disc, in the case of this Naxos reissue, the Unfinished Symphony. Admittedly, the
companion piece is only two movements long, but that’s not the point. It’s just
an amazing world we take for granted these days.
Anyway, Hungarian conductor Michael Halasz gets the album
started with the Symphony No. 8 in B
minor, D759 “Unfinished,” which
Franz Schubert (1797-1828) began writing around 1822 but never finished before
moving along to other things. Halasz leads the Slovak Philharmonic Orchestra in
a sympathetic performance.
I especially liked what Maestro Halasz does with the
opening of the Eighth, beginning with
a more than usually dark opening and moving on to a sweetly casual lilt,
turning as it should into alternately light and heavy sections. Halasz
maintains an exceptionally airy tone in the more lyrical passages, particularly
in the second-movement Andante, that
is most pleasant.
The history of Schubert’s last numbered symphony, the Symphony No. 9 in C major, D944, the
“Great,” is somewhat odd because while the composer dated it 1828, the year of
his death, he probably didn’t actually write it in 1828. In fact, it may not
have even been his last symphony. The odds are he wrote it earlier than 1828,
maybe 1826, which makes little difference since, as with the rest of Schubert’s
orchestral music, he never published any of it, anyway. The public didn’t hear
the Ninth until 1839, eleven years
after the composer died. Anymore, audiences consider it one of the staples of
the classical music world.
Here, Maestro Halasz leads the Failoni Chamber Orchestra
of the Hungarian State Opera in a reading that impressed me less than his Eighth. With a relatively small group,
around a third the size of the Slovak Philharmonic, Halasz exhibits less power
than I would have liked in this work and less dynamic punch. I can understand
using a small period-instruments band for historical reasons and perhaps a
small ensemble for greater transparency, but the Ninth is a big work that usually benefits from a bigger orchestra.
With the Failoni Orchestra it sounds rather lightweight.
Halasz’s leisurely pace doesn’t do a lot to drum up much
enthusiasm, either. Instead, the piece just seems to drift aimlessly along,
without much spirit. Even the conductor’s sudden tempo shifts do little to
generate much excitement. A steady but rigid Andante march and a fleet-footed but cheerless Scherzo hardly help the situation. The fact is, the whole
performance appears more than a tad bland. Fortunately, it ends in a reasonably
joyful Finale, although it’s probably
a matter of too little too late.
Naxos recorded the Symphony
No. 8 at the Moyzes Hall, Bratislava, in 1988 and the Symphony No. 9 at the Italian Institute in Budapest in 1994. The
company initially released the two recordings separately, with different
couplings, and then together in this 2012 rerelease. In the Eighth, we hear very good sonics with
more than adequate body and size. Dynamics are fine, too, and the midrange
sounds warm and smooth. While the stereo spread seems slightly constricted,
there is a realistic sense of depth involved. In the Ninth the smaller orchestra does, indeed, afford a greater clarity
throughout, although the hall imparts a bit too much reflective resonance,
nullifying some of the benefits of the smaller ensemble. I preferred the more
natural acoustic of the Eighth to the
inordinately reverberant setting of the Ninth.
Still, both recordings make for comfortable, easy, if somewhat dull, listening.
Here’s the thing, though: Unless you’re a dedicated
collector of everything ever recorded or just a die-hard Schubert fan, you may
find better recordings of the Eighth
from Otto Klemperer (EMI), Giuseppe Sinopoli (DG), Eugen Jochum (DG), Charles
Munch (RCA), or Charles Mackerras (Virgin) and of the Ninth from Josef Krips (Decca/HDTT), Otto Klemperer (EMI) and
Charles Mackerras again (Virgin or Telarc), Georg Solti (Decca), George Szell
(Sony), or Gunther Wand (RCA).
To hear a brief excerpt from this album, click here:
JJP
To hear a brief excerpt from this album, click here:
JJP
