A Collection of the
Most Innovative High-End Audio Recordings by Northstar Recording. Various
artists. Turtle Records TRSA75538.
It’s a standard Redbook CD. It’s an SACD. It’s a Blu-ray
disc. It’s FLAC file in PCM surround and stereo. It’s in two-channel stereo.
It’s in 5.1-channel DTS-HD Master Audio. It’s in 2.0-channel LPCM. Yes, it’s an
audiophile release. Or, more precisely, it’s a two-disc box set from Northstar
Recording Services and Turtle Records, a sampler of some of their best work,
jazz and classical, from over a dozen of their previously released albums.
As the folks at Northstar explain it, “This High
Definition Surround Recording was produced, engineered and edited by Bert van
der Wolf of Northstar Recording Services, using the ‘High quality Musical
Surround Mastering’ principle. The basis of this recording principle is a
realistic and holographic 3 dimensional representation of the musical instruments,
voices and recording venue.” You’ll find the music in multiple formats,
including regular two-channel stereo playable on any CD player; two-channel and
5.1 SACD playable on a Super Audio Compact Disc player; and LPCM stereo and
DTS-HD Master Audio multichannel from a Blu-ray player. There’s a little
something here for everyone, but even though I have a Blu-ray player in my
home-theater room, I listened mainly in two-channel SACD in my living system
(going to the 5.1 DTS-HD MA format later for comparison purposes).
The idea behind these recordings is to capture, as the
company says, “only the music.” Turtle Records, dCS, Northstar Recordings
Services, and Kompas CD Multimedia have been doing this sort of thing for
years, and the current discs include material from two decades of recording,
all of them remastered and updated for a variety of today’s audio formats. I
won’t try to cover everything, but I will mention a few of the tracks that
stand out.
First up is what producer and engineer Bert van der Wolf
says is the very first Turtle Records production, "Teardrops for
Jimmy" with Tony Overwater and Maarten Ornstein. The pair play soft, quiet
jazz, very pleasant, and the sound is most lifelike in its clarity and
definition, yet warm and natural, too.
Next, we hear the Marc van Roon Trio doing "Noodling
Effect," three guys just noodling around, improvising, on their
instruments: piano, percussion, and bass. The music didn't particularly
interest me, but the dimensionality of the sound is impressive, the clearly
perceived distances between each player and their location within the recording
environment.
The third selection is with a big ensemble, the
Netherlands Philharmonic under Mario Venzago playing an excerpt from Gershwin's
An American in Paris. The performance
provides vigor and excitement, while the sound is remarkably transparent for a
big group of players, the clarity and dynamics making one wish we had the whole
thing to hear. Which, I suppose, is the point of any sampler--to persuade the listener
to buy the complete album from which the music comes.
And so it goes, each track a delight to the ears. Among
the things I liked best I would include Michael Gees improvising on a piano
piece by Erik Satie; lovely and beautifully recorded. Then there's the opening
movement of Beethoven's Fifth Symphony
exhibiting enormous impact, probably as much power as I've ever heard in a
recording of this work. Christoph Pregardien singing Schumann's "Mein
Wagen rollet langsam" sounds sweet and nuanced, both artistically and
sonically. I also couldn't help liking the concluding track, "Mars,"
performed by Dean Peer and Ty Burhoe; it's audiophile the whole way with its
precisely defined percussion, quick transient response, and wide-ranging
dynamics. All of it fun stuff.
Two concerns, though: First, Turtle Records have packaged
the two discs in a 5” x 10” longbox, as pictured above, rather than in a
regular double jewel case. The two discs fasten to the top of an inside
cardboard platform, and a twelve-page booklet stretches the length of the box.
When I used to review movies, some of the studios would send out special box
sets, too, and the problem was that I never knew where to put them. The longbox
doesn’t fit on an ordinary record shelf, so you can’t really put it in among
your other discs. You have to find a special place for the box or maybe keep it
in a closet. Of course, you could always jerry-rig a jewel case or Blu-ray case
for the two discs, but that doesn’t solve the issue of the booklet notes being
the length of the original box. I dunno. Maybe you like special gift boxes and
stack them in a corner or proudly display them somewhere. I dunno. A minor
concern. Second, Turtle Records have priced the set rather high. For some
people, maybe not a minor concern.
JJP
To listen to a brief excerpt from this album, click here:
To listen to a brief excerpt from this album, click here:
